您当前的位置: > 详细浏览

科研诚信的度量困难与非理性风险:面向科研诚信外部规范技术进路的学理反思

The measurement difficulties and irrational risks of scientific research integrity: a theoretical reflection on the technical approach to external norms of scientific research integrity

摘要:为深入探讨科研诚信外部规范相关价值体系层级和技术进路,基于多学科理论视域对科研诚信度量评价制度化实践的困难根源与非理性风险进行了具体考察和学理反思,明晰了:①科研诚信的伦理本质及其评价的社会关系型实践特质;②规范科研场域的应然价值尺度和科研著述的原初功能属性;③依托公共权威度量评价科研诚信的制度化逻辑及制度锁定风险;④优化技术进路和制度供给的未来方向。研究结论对于避免盲目的制度迁移与技术借鉴、构建有利于本国科学技术体系自立自强的制度优势、推进科研诚信从危机应对向长效治理转化,具有基础性的理论支撑意义。

英文摘要:In order to deeply explore the value system levels and technical approaches related to the external norms of scientific research integrity, based on a multidisciplinary theoretical perspective, the difficulties and irrational risks of the institutionalized practice of the measurement and evaluation of scientific research integrity have been specifically investigated and theoretically reflected, and it is clear that: ① Scientific research The ethical nature of honesty and the social relational practical characteristics of its evaluation; ② the standard value scale of scientific research fields and the original functional attributes of scientific research writings; ③ the institutionalized logic and institutional locking risk of evaluating scientific research integrity by relying on public authority metrics; ④ Optimize the future direction of technological approach and institutional supply. The research conclusions have fundamental theoretical support significance for avoiding blind institutional migration and technical reference, building institutional advantages that are conducive to the self-reliance and self-improvement of the national science and technology system, and promoting the transformation of scientific research integrity from crisis response to long-term governance.

版本历史

[V4] 2022-07-10 16:19:28 chinaXiv:202102.00076V4 下载全文
[V3] 2022-07-02 22:40:57 chinaXiv:202102.00076v3 查看此版本 下载全文
[V2] 2022-03-13 22:07:26 chinaXiv:202102.00076v2 查看此版本 下载全文
[V1] 2021-02-20 21:59:28 chinaXiv:202102.00076v1 查看此版本 下载全文
点击下载全文
同行评议状态
待评议
许可声明
metrics指标
  • 点击量24197
  • 下载量1668
评论
分享
邀请专家评阅